| IMGs Outperform USIMGs. Papa Doc’s Caribbean Med School. |
|
|
| Written by Dr. Eugenio G. Amparo Batch 1972b | |
|
Abbreviations: IMG, International Medical Graduate; USIMG, U.S. citizen who attended medical school outside the United States or Canada; ECFMG, Educational Commission for Foreign Medical Graduates “The characteristics of the pool of IMGs seeking ECFMG certification have changed over time. For example, increasing numbers of foreign students applying for certification have attended medical school outside their native countries. More noteworthy, more U.S. citizens have attended medical school outside the United States or Canada. This latter group, referred to as USIMGs, consists of second-generation Americans who sought education in the home country of their parents, people who were not successful with applications to U.S. [medical schools], and others who simply preferred an international training experience.” [2] --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Those of you who are fans of Garry Trudeau’s [1] comic strip, Doonesbury, remember Zonker Harris, the laid-back, pot-smoking hippie whose only passions in college were drugs, tanning and house plants (which talked back to him). He won the Jack Ford Medal for Best Tan at the 1980 Gerald R Ford Summer Biathlon (the two sports being golf and tanning). After graduating from college, he was a student at the Papa Doc Medical School in Haiti. In one episode, Zonker was lying on the beach, obviously depressed. When asked why he was depressed when he had just topped the neurosurgery examination, he replied that he had lost the tanning contest. Zonker Harris represents the U.S. citizen who failed to gain admission to a U.S. medical school and consequently attended a foreign medical school. Those of us [5] who were foreigners and therefore attended foreign medical schools, perform better than U.S. citizens who go to foreign medical schools, according to one study.[2] “International medical graduates (IMGs) constitute approximately 25 percent of practicing physicians in the United States, a level of participation that has increased from 18 percent in 1970 and only 10 percent in 1963.” [2]
“The number of U.S. citizens attending medical schools outside the United States and Canada has increased recently. Because these people tend to return to the United States to practice medicine, it is important to know more about their characteristics and educational experiences. Based on summary data from certifying examinations, U.S. citizens trained abroad do not perform as well as either other international medical graduates (IMGs) or U.S. graduates. Moreover, they are more likely than non-U.S. citizens to be engaged in primary care activities. Changes in the composition of the IMG pool could affect the makeup and quality of the U.S. physician workforce.” [2] The findings in the above study deserve consideration by all UPMASAns who have strong opinions about the UPCM’s return service obligation [3], particularly those who may be upset about its effect on their children who seek admission to the UPCM. Even more compelling is the cost of medical education in a U.S. medical school, estimated to be $140,000 for public schools and $225,000 for private schools. [4] The cost of medical school at UPCM, including the penalty and interest payments for defaulting on the return service obligation, would still be a bargain by comparison. A third consideration is the discontinuation of the Fifth Pathway Program as of June 30, 2009.[6] The final argument lies in the right of the UPCM to dictate policy, independent of the opinions of those who donate money to UP-PGH, such as members of the UPMASA. Notes and references: 1. “In 1975, Trudeau became the first comic strip artist ever to be awarded a Pulitzer Prize for editorial cartooning. He was a Pulitzer Prize finalist in 1989, 2004 and 2005. Working with John and Faith Hubley, Trudeau wrote and co-directed the animated film, A Doonesbury Special, for NBC-TV in 1977. The film was nominated for an Academy Award and received the Special Jury Prize at the Cannes Film Festival.” http://www.doonesbury.com/strip/faqs/cv.html 2. U.S. Citizens Who Obtain Their Medical Degrees Abroad: An Overview, 1992-2006. Health Aff. 2009;28(1):226-233. ©2009 Project HOPE. Posted 03/09/2009. http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/587050_print 3. “All graduates of the University of the Philippines-Manila (UPM) College of Medicine will soon be required to render a three-year return service to the country after graduating and obtaining a medical license. The new policy is expected to cover incoming medical students beginning academic year 2009-2010. Under the policy, applicants to the College need to sign a contract as part of requirements for their admission to the college. The contract stipulates a return service, which may be in the form of public service, research, or private practice in any part of the Philippines, after obtaining a Philippine medical license. As part of the return service, a graduate may choose to undergo post-graduate residency and/or fellowship training in any government institution in Metro Manila or in any public or private institution outside Metro Manila. The return service should be completed within five years from graduation. Graduates who fail to comply will be required to pay a penalty, which will be double the value of the amount of state subsidy used for their education, with interest at legal rates.” http://www.up.edu.ph/features.php?i=88 4. "The cost of obtaining a medical education has been spiraling upward for the past 20 years. Despite a lot of rhetoric in articles and at meetings of the Association of American Medical Colleges, nothing has happened to change the alarming pattern. The average tuition and fees at public medical schools during the 2003–2004 academic year amounted to $16,153, and the corresponding figure for private schools was $32,588.3 Adding $20,000 to $25,000 for living expenses, books, and equipment brings the estimated cost of four years of attendance to about $140,000 for public schools and $225,000 for private schools." – The New England Journal of Medicine. Volume 352:117-119. January 13, 2005. Number 2 http://content.nejm.org/cgi/content/extract/352/2/117 5. I am a foreign medical graduate. I was born in the Philippines and grew up in Iloilo City. After graduating from the University of the Philippines in Iloilo City, I went to UPCM and graduated in 1972. I interned at the Veterans’ Memorial Hospital in Quezon City. 1974-1978: radiology residency at the University of Texas Medical Branch (UTMB), Galveston, TX. 1978: certified by the American Board of Radiology; became a naturalized U.S. citizen. 1983-1984: fellowship in MRI at the University of California San Francisco (UCSF), the year clinical MRI was introduced at UCSF. I myself have not fulfilled any service to the UPCM in return for my medical education. I have a son and a daughter, neither of whom ever entertained the idea of going to medical school. 6. “As of June 30, 2009, through action of the AMA Council on Medical Education (CME Report 1-I-07), the Fifth Pathway will be discontinued. The Council will no longer support the Fifth Pathway as a mechanism for eligibility to enter the first year of ACGME-accredited graduate medical education programs. The AMA will continue to maintain record of former graduates of Fifth Pathway programs, but will cease to add records of individuals completing a year of supervised clinical education at an LCME-accredited medical school in the US after July 1, 2009. The last Fifth Pathway Program class to be supported is the January 2009 entering class, which ends December 2009.” “[The Fifth Pathway is] an avenue by which students who have attended four years at a foreign medical school may complete their supervised clinical work at a U.S. medical school, become eligible for entry to U.S. residency training, and ultimately obtain a license to practice in the U.S.” “Who can qualify for a Fifth Pathway? Only students who: 1. Graduated from an accredited American college or university; 2. Studied medicine at a medical school located outside the United States that is listed in World Health Organization's World Directory of Medical Schools and which requires a year or more of internship/social service (beyond the four years of medical school) before receiving a medical degree; 3. Completed all formal requirements of their foreign medical school except the final year(s) of clinical work/social service. 4. Students must be a citizen, resident alien, or Canadian Citizen with a student visa.” --American Medical Association http://www.ama-assn.org/ama/pub/about-ama/our-people/ama-councils/council-medical-education/topics/the-fifth-pathway-program.shtml
|
| Next > |
|---|
|
Studio 23's Primetime News features the Mu Sigma Phi along with the 2008 TAYO Winners, with the fraternity represented by Kiev Tanayan ΜΣΦ 2012 in a short interview. The Mu Sigma Phi became the first fraternity to win the TAYO Award. |
|
Mu Sigma Phi's Our Strong Band finished first place at the Friday at the East (FATE) 2009. Martin Banez ΜΣΦ 2011, on lead guitar, literally struts his stuff and showed everyone that he is the only REAL lead guitarist that played that night. |
|
Mu Sigma Phi's number at the Tao Rin Pala 2009. Watch as the entire fraternity performs a "stomp" routine. Turn up the volume to hear a very familiar chant to the tune of LMFAO's sh*ts, err... Shots. |
|
Orthopedic surgeons Dr. Joel Ignacio МΣΦ 1985 and Dr. Rafael Bundoc МΣΦ 1986 interviewed by ABS-CBN's Salamat Dok for performing the world's first Cervical Interfacet Distraction Decompression procedure. |
| Brotherhood |
| Leadership |
| Scholarship |
| Service |